MINUTEMAN REVIEW may be compensated for purchases done through links on our site. To learn more about this, you can read through our Affiliate Disclaimer here.
Whether you’re new to handguns or an experienced shooter, the caliber you choose can make a significant difference to your ability to defend yourself, hunt, or win trophies. Every caliber has its strengths and drawbacks, so it’s worth investigating the best options on the market.
Which Pistol Caliber is Best?
There is no right pistol caliber for every shooting task. If you intend to buy a handgun for self-defense, target practice, or hunting, you should know what caliber is best suited for that purpose. There are many pistol calibers to choose from, so it’s important to understand the basics to make an informed decision.
Rimfire vs. Centerfire
There are, broadly, two types of handgun cartridge: Rimfire and centerfire. This refers to the location of the primer or priming compound in the cartridge case. In a centerfire round, the primer is located in the center of the cartridge case head. In a rimfire round, the priming compound is contained inside the rim.
The primer is the first part of the ignition chain. When you squeeze the trigger, the firing pin strikes the primer, crushing it. As the primer contains an impact-sensitive explosive, this detonates it, igniting the propellant charge.
Centerfire cartridges are more reliable, suffering fewer misfires. They also tend to be more powerful. As a result, centerfire pistol calibers are the preferred choice for self-defense. Rimfire rounds are lighter caliber and less expensive, so they’re used for varmint hunting and plinking.
.380 ACP (9mm Short, 9×17mm Browning)
John Browning designed the .380 ACP in 1908. Since then, the cartridge has been popular as a self-defense round in highly concealable compact and subcompact handguns. While this round is by no means a powerhouse, it allows you to carry a light weapon with minimal recoil.
9mm Luger (9×19mm Parabellum)
The first handgun to fire the 10mm Auto cartridge was the famous Dornaus & Dixon Bren Ten. This pistol, introduced in 1983, was ultimately a failure because of production setbacks. However, the 10mm round gained a popular following due to its power and silver-screen presence on the TV show Miami Vice.
In 1990, the FBI adopted a service pistol chambered in a reduced-pressure 10mm load. In its full-power loadings, the 10mm Auto cartridge can exceed the performance of the .357 Magnum but in a semi-automatic pistol.
In 1990, Smith & Wesson, in cooperation with Winchester, developed the .40 Smith & Wesson cartridge. The design replicates the FBI’s 10mm load ballistics in a medium (i.e., 9mm) handgun frame.
Development of the .45 ACP cartridge, also called the .45 Auto, began in 1905. However, it wasn’t until 1911 that the U.S. Army adopted it. Having served the United States in World War I, World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War, among other skirmishes, the .45 ACP has a battle-proven legacy.
In 1985, the .45-caliber Beretta M9 replaced m1911A1 as the standard sidearm of the U.S. armed forces. However, it continues to endure in the hands of private citizens. Prized for its stopping power among big-bore enthusiasts, the .45 ACP is used extensively in self-defense and competitive target shooting.
This is the quintessential double-action revolver cartridge. The .38 Special, introduced in 1898 by Smith & Wesson, has been a mainstay for police service revolvers and snub-nosed wheel guns for concealed carry. Although police officers rarely carry service revolvers as sidearms anymore, private citizens use snub-nosed revolvers for concealed carry.
Introduced in 1935, the .357 Magnum is derived from the .38 Special but lengthened. The .357 Magnum propels the same weight and diameter bullets at considerably higher muzzle velocities.
The increased length prevents the .357 Magnum cartridge from being chambered in .38-caliber revolvers, which cannot handle the significantly increased chamber pressure. However, you can fire .38 Special cartridges in .357 Magnum revolvers, allowing for less expensive and lower-recoil target practice.
Once called “the most powerful handgun in the world,” most gun owners probably associate the .44 Magnum with the Dirty Harry films. However, this round was introduced 15 years earlier, in 1956. The product of experiments by Elmer Keith, the .44 Magnum is no longer the most powerful handgun in the world, but it’s no slouch, either. Suitable for hunting and defense against dangerous game, the .44 Magnum is known for its stout recoil and penetrating power.
Eclipsing the .44 Magnum in muzzle velocity and kinetic energy, this round is not for the faint of heart. However, its power allows it to be a versatile hunting cartridge. The .454 Casull, along with the .460 Smith & Wesson Magnum, is also an excellent choice for defense against brown and grizzly bears.
The primary reason to investigate pistols calibers, as with rifle calibers, is to determine what round fulfills your requirements. If you need a caliber for self-defense, you need to balance several considerations. These include portability, controllability, capacity, and power.
The 9mm, .40 S&W, .45 ACP, and .357 Magnum cartridges are excellent self-defense choices. Though 9mm is the most affordable and widely available handgun caliber.
The .44 Magnum and .454 Casull cartridges primarily serve two purposes — hunting and defense against dangerous game. Although these cartridges can be used for self-defense against humans, this is not practical. If you want to keep a handgun in your home or vehicle for self-defense, concealability may not be a priority. Under those conditions, you can opt for a full-size handgun.
As the concealability increases, there is less gripping surface. The result is less control regarding recoil.
To be better understand the anatomy of bullets, check this article about basic parts of ammo.