Is a Muzzle Brake Better Than a Flash Hider?

MINUTEMAN REVIEW may be compensated for purchases done through links on our site. To learn more about this, you can read through our Affiliate Disclaimer here.

Last Updated on May 18, 2021.
Is a Muzzle Brake Better Than a Flash Hider

There are numerous muzzle devices available for handguns, rifles, and shotguns. Two of the most common types are muzzle brakes and flash hiders. For the best results, you should understand the differences between them and which you may need.


Muzzle Devices


The end of a rifle, handgun, or shotgun barrel is called the muzzle. In some firearms, this is simply crowned. In others, the muzzle is threaded to accept a muzzle device. 

Whether you need a muzzle brake or flash hider, or no device at all, depends on the type of weapon and the application for which you intend to employ it. While muzzle brakes and flash hiders are often confused with one another, they serve different purposes. It’s worth understanding the differences before you purchase one.


Muzzle Brakes vs. Flash Hiders

Regardless of whether you’re a hunter, tactical shooter, or 3-Gun competitor, a muzzle device of one kind or another can help you in multiple ways. If you want to answer the “muzzle brake vs. flash hider” debate to your satisfaction, you should know the basic differences between the two devices.

Flash hiders

A flash hider also called a flash suppressor, is designed to reduce the brightness of the muzzle flash by dissipating the expanding powder gases that leave the muzzle, typically through a series of longitudinal slots. Two common types of flash hider include the birdcage and the three-prong

The birdcage type consists of a closed cylindrical flash hider with slots that exhaust gases circumferentially. The three-prong type is an open flash hider with three tines that vent gases in three directions. There are variations of both designs that seek to increase the efficiency of gas dissipation, minimize vibration, or add other features.

The muzzle flash can be temporarily blinding in low light or total darkness, especially in short-barreled rifles. The flash hider can help you preserve your night vision and situational awareness. That’s the primary purpose of the flash hider. 

A Word on Short-Barreled Rifles

If a muzzle device, such as a flash hider, is readily detachable, it does not affect the legal length of a rifle’s barrel. However, if the flash hider is pinned and welded, it can extend the length of a barrel from, for example, 12.5” to 16”, thus enabling compliance with the National Firearms Act. If you’re in the process of building a semi-automatic reproduction of a military carbine, this can be a beneficial strategy. 

Visibility

The flash hider can also reduce the visual firing signature. However, this is not the primary purpose. It’s common to see news-media pundits and lawmakers insist that a flash hider can render a gunman invisible at night, concealing his position from authorities and victims alike. It’s worth noting that many flash hiders cannot eliminate the flash entirely—and the device does not eliminate the report. 

Muzzle brakes

A muzzle brake, which is often cylindrical, square, or rectangular, is designed to reduce rearward recoil. It exerts a braking effect on the rifle. Although related to compensators, Muzzle brakes are different as a compensator aims to minimize muzzle flip. 

The addition of a muzzle brake is one of the simplest ways of reducing the recoil of a rifle or shotgun without significantly increasing the weapon’s weight. 

When gases leave the muzzle following the bullet, they impact baffles in the muzzle brake or the edges of circular exhaust ports. These gases apply forward pressure, which pulls the brake and the gun forward. Consequently, the more powerful the rifle cartridge and the higher the gas pressure, the more potentially effective the brake. Many muzzle brakes also deflect these gases in the direction opposite to that of the recoil impulse.   

Regardless of the design, the brake usually exhausts gases laterally. There are better options if you need to control muzzle climb, but the muzzle brake is the best choice for powerful weapons. That’s why anti-materiel rifles—e.g., those chambered in .50 BMG—and magnum hunting rifles often sport muzzle brakes. 

The recoil in some firearms can cause discomfort and shooter fatigue. In others, it may be potentially harmful. Several factors affect the perceived recoil of a rifle, from cartridge and weight to stock design and action. Some are complicated to alter, while others are not. 

The muzzle brake offers a cost-effective, general-purpose solution to the recoil problem that doesn’t require too much tinkering with the weapon. 

Which is Better?

The answer to “muzzle brake vs. flash hider” depends on what you need it for. Neither the muzzle brake nor the flash hider is strictly better—they serve different purposes. 

For firearms that do not require recoil reduction but may benefit from a less prominent muzzle flash, the flash hider is the appropriate choice. For rifles that don’t produce a blinding muzzle flash but produce recoil deemed uncomfortable, the muzzle brake is the default option. These devices do not necessarily overlap in function. 

For example, an AR-15 rifle chambered in .223 Remington/5.56mm NATO does not produce significant recoil. Children can often handle this rifle without difficulty.  However, depending on the barrel length, the muzzle flash can be relatively bright, especially when firing at dawn or dusk; therefore, a flash hider would be the preferred choice of muzzle device. 

In contrast, a bolt-action Winchester Model 70 in .375 H&H Magnum or a Barrett M95 in .50 BMG can produce recoil that many shooters find distinctly unpleasant. The muzzle flash is less of a concern than the recoil impulse that these weapons deliver to the shoulder, so a muzzle brake is the best option for taming these guns. 

Shotguns

Rifles are not the only weapons that can benefit from the use of a muzzle brake. Shotguns are known for their recoil, especially when firing magnum loads. The use of a muzzle brake can help attenuate the recoil impulse, allowing you to fire more shotshells during a range session or hunting trip. 

Noise

Both types of muzzle devices can increase the report of a firearm, but muzzle brakes are notorious for this. While it’s always advisable to wear appropriate hearing protection when discharging firearms or being in proximity to them, you should exercise extra caution when using weapons that exhaust and redirect gases for recoil mitigation. 

Debris

Many muzzle brake designs exhaust more gas than flash hiders, disrupting dirt, dust, and debris from the ground when firing from the prone position. You should also be careful about placing delicate tools or instruments near the barrel—the muzzle blast may blow them over.


Check Your Local Laws

The legality of muzzle devices in general, and flash suppressors and muzzle brakes specifically, varies from one jurisdiction to another. It’s essential you investigate your state and local laws to ensure that these devices are legal for you to own. In some states, a rifle with a threaded muzzle is restricted. 


Final Thoughts

Muzzle brake or flash hider, the device that’s right for you, depends on your weapons and field of interest.